About Us

New England Indemnity Company is a modern insurance company with New England roots, dedicated to providing reliable insurance solutions through our exclusive network of independent agents. Based in Bedford, NH, we are proud to combine the traditional values of trust, stability, and service with a fresh perspective and innovative approach to insurance.

JOHN ELIAS

Chief Executive Officer

Mr. Elias, who holds a J.D. and an MBA, joined the Company in January of 2024. He has over 25 years of insurance experience. Mr. Elias is a respected, commercial lines underwriting executive with substantial systems experience who also previously served as Insurance Commissioner for New Hampshire.

MICHELLE PEZONE

Chief Underwriting Officer

Ms. Pezone has 18 years of experience in the property and casualty business with a primary focus on personal lines. Her experience includes specific responsibility for developing and implementing profitable personal lines strategies throughout the northeastern United States.

LORI SHERMAN

Chief Marketing Officer
Ms. Sherman has over 25 years of experience in the property and casualty business with a focus on both Marketing/Territory Management and Personal Lines Underwriting and was most recently employed by Central Mutual and Westfield Insurance companies. Her primary responsibility is developing, supporting, and growing independent agency relationships in support of the Company’s distribution strategy.

CHRIS NORTON

Vice President of Claims

Mr. Norton has 22 years of experience in property & casualty claims both on the carrier and independent adjusting firm sides. His experience includes adjusting personal lines and commercial lines claims, as well as managing adjusters, overseeing the Northeast US, and directing divisions of National IA firms. He will be driving claims performance and customer satisfaction through the claims process.

JAMES CAREW

Chief Financial and Administrative Officer

Mr. Carew is a CPA and holds CFA and CPCU designations. He has held significant managerial and operational positions in the insurance industry, with over 30 years’ experience with carriers and TPAs in the areas of finance, reinsurance, systems and administration. Early in his career he worked in the accounting division of Mt. Washington Assurance, then a New Hampshire domestic, startup property and casualty company owned by Plymouth Rock. Mr. Carew is also a director of NEIC and NEIC Services.

KHRYSTIE PARKS

Director of Underwriting

Ms. Parks, CPCU, ARM, ARM-P, CRIS, MRIS has 23 years of experience in Property and Casualty Insurance with a primary focus on Commercial Lines (BOP, small and large commercial, middle market).  Her experience includes product development and implementation, as well as commercial lines underwriting.

JANET SHUEY

Customer Support Specialist

Ms. Shuey has over 25 years’ experience in the Mortgage Industry as oversight in operations for processing and closing mortgage loans.  She has 6 years of property casualty experience as a Personal Lines agent covering a full book of business.  She was also a Finance Manager for a local marina writing insurance coverage for new boats in New Hampshire.

DONALD J. PFUNDSTEIN, ESQUIRE

General Counsel

Attorney Pfundstein has advised the senior management and directors of property and casualty insurance companies on a wide range of strategic, regulatory, governance, compliance, transactional, licensing, relationship, expansion and other matters for over 25 years.

Our Mission

Our mission is to empower our clients with comprehensive, customizable insurance options that fit their unique needs and budgets. We are committed to fostering strong relationships with our agency partners and delivering exceptional service that exceeds expectations. We strive to be a trusted partner for our clients, providing peace of mind through reliable and straightforward insurance solutions.

Our Vision

Our vision is to be the leading choice for insurance in New England, known for our commitment to our clients, our agents, and our community. We aim to set a new standard in the insurance industry by blending the best of traditional values with innovative solutions, ensuring that every client feels valued, protected, and confident in their coverage.

Customer Focus

We are dedicated to meeting our clients’ needs with exceptional service and provide the best solutions.

100%

Independent Agent Network

NE Indemnity exclusively partners with independent agents, ensuring that all of our clients receive personalized service and unbiased insurance options.

15+

Years of Combined Industry Experience

Our leadership team brings over 15 years of combined experience in the insurance and real estate sectors, providing a strong foundation for a company built on expertise and trust.

Partnership

We value our relationships with independent agents and work closely with them to deliver superior solutions.

What makes us different

We partner exclusively with independent agents who live and work in your community. They’re not just representatives—they’re local experts who know your area, your challenges, and your needs. By working with agents who represent multiple companies, we offer more than just policies; we offer choices. This means you get the right coverage at the right price, with the personal touch that only a dedicated agent can provide.

Tailored Coverage Options for Over 10 Types of Insurance

Offering a diverse range of products including home, auto, business, and specialty insurance, we ensure our clients have access to the coverage they need.

Fast Claims Processing

NE Indemnity strives to process claims within 5 business days, ensuring quick and efficient support during critical times.

Customer Satisfaction Goal

With a focus on exceptional service, NE Indemnity aims to achieve a 90% customer satisfaction rate by providing responsive claims support and personalized insurance solutions.

Why Choose NE Indemnity?

In a world where many insurance companies have been around for centuries, NE Indemnity stands out as a new and dynamic player, deeply connected to the heritage and communities of New England. We are committed to providing exceptional insurance solutions through our exclusive network of independent agents who represent multiple companies. This approach ensures that our clients receive personalized service and unbiased advice, allowing them to choose from a wide array of coverage options tailored to their specific needs.

As a fresh face in a market dominated by centuries-old companies, we bring a new perspective that blends traditional values of trust and reliability with modern, innovative approaches to insurance. We prioritize:

Partnership You Need

We work with independent agents who represent multiple companies, ensuring you get the best coverage tailored to your needs.

Stability & Reliability

With a foundation built on trust and experience, we bring the reliability you expect from a traditional insurance provider.

24/7 Support and Easy Claims

Count on our dedicated support team to assist you around the clock. With streamlined claims processing, getting the help you need is fast and stress-free.